REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION
DATE: 05/05/2021
TO: Honorable Mayor and City Council Members
FROM: Community Services Department
SUBJECT:
Title
Ordinance amending the Corona Municipal Code Chapter 12.22 Community Forestry Program to include an Urban Forest Management Plan and Adopt Resolution 2021-029 approving an Urban Forest Management Plan.
End
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
The proposed Urban Forest Management Plan (UFMP) was developed as a guide for standard operating procedures (SOP) for maintaining and managing the City’s Urban Forest. The UFMP focuses on the methodology to perform tree inspections, routine maintenance, removals, and a comprehensive list of all City approved trees for planting. The UFMP establishes guidelines and procedures for the care and protection of trees to promote the health, safety, welfare, and quality of life for all Corona residents, business owners, and visitors.
RECOMMENDED ACTION:
Recommended action
That the City Council:
a. Introduce by title only and waive full reading for consideration of Ordinance No. 3328 first reading of an ordinance amending Corona Municipal Code Chapter 12.22 (Community Forestry Program) of the Corona Municipal Code to change the chapter title, to incorporate an Urban Forest Management Plan, and to amend all sections to incorporate updated landscape guidelines.
b. Adopt Resolution No. 2021-029, of the City Council of the City of Corona, California approving an Urban Forest Management Plan.
c. Provide direction on the frequency of reforestation for vacant tree sites throughout the City and whether a resident can refuse a tree.
d. Provide direction on preferred grid pruning cycles throughout the City.
Body
BACKGROUND & HISTORY:
Prior to the implementation of the proposed Urban Forest Management Plan, the City followed the practices outlined under Corona Municipal Code Section (CMC) 12.22 Community Forestry Program. While the City has a routine tree maintenance program, it is fairly dependent upon resident requests, and under the recommendation of the City Arborist. While this practice has worked for many years, it can be improved to address vacant tree sites and improve maintenance standards throughout the City. Currently, the City has over 14,000 tree sites which remain empty with no set plan or standard in place to restore these missing trees, which offer a number of benefits to their respective neighborhoods. The City currently provides regular pruning for approximately 7,500 trees annually, but we believe we can do even better with a more proactive plan set in place for programmed service intervals.
To improve maintenance and begin work to restore the urban forest, staff have researched plans from other cities, professional service agencies, and worked with its own consultants to seek a proactive solution for Corona’s residents. The proposed UFMP was developed with standards set by the International Society of Arboriculture’s (ISA) in mind to create guidelines for tree inspection, trimming, pruning, and removal of City trees. The UFMP has been created in a collaborative partnership with the California Urban Forests Council, Western Chapter International Society of Arboriculture utilizing funding from Proposition 68, administered through CAL FIRE’s Urban and Community Forestry Grant Program.
To implement the UFMP, staff will continue to work with its contracted vendor, currently West Coast Arborists, in conjunction with the City’s licensed Arborist, to ensure these standards are being upheld.
ANALYSIS:
As the City begins to set goals as part of its newly adopted Strategic Plan, structured operating procedures must be put in place. The Comprehensive changes to CMC Chapter 12.22 and the Urban Forest Management Plan will provide a set of standard operating procedures for routine tree maintenance as well as proactively evaluating and maintaining the City’s urban forest. The UFMP outlines best management practices and provides consistent information to maintain a healthy and sustainable urban forest following principles established through the ISA. Residents will be able to access this information, as well as resources, through the Community Services Department and its corresponding media channels.
The City of Corona acknowledges there are many benefits that an urban forest provides to the community. These benefits are wide-ranging across environmental, aesthetic, social, and economic areas. Specifically, trees increase property values, provide aesthetic value, provide shade and cooling, reduce energy costs, decrease wind velocities, provide erosion control, conserve energy, reduce stormwater runoff, and act as filters for airborne pollutants.
This UFMP allows the City to more effectively implement best management practices that will provide clear, transparent guidance for both residents and staff to provide consistent and accurate information regarding the management of the City’s urban forest. The UFMP will allow staff to provide our residents with even more outstanding, consistent customer response and service. In addition, it also provides residents a process to voice any concerns or appeals through a systematic public platform.
In reviewing the UFMP, it became necessary to look at the CMC. City staff reviewed Chapter 12.22 (Community Forestry Program) and noted that there were portions of the Chapter which needed to be modified to better implement the UFMP. Community Services staff has worked with the City Attorney to analyze Chapter 12.22 of the CMC and other related documents. The proposed ordinance reflects the work done to amend the CMC to implement and support the UFMP. As part of the implementation of the UFMP, staff can recommend the following practices to be adopted to ensure the successful reestablishment and continued care for the City’s urban forest. Further details and cost implications of the proposed options below are highlighted in the Financial Impact section of this report.
Reforestation
A healthy urban forest is something that will enhance the look and livability of the City of Corona. With an urban forest, there are both benefits and potential liability. To present a balanced picture to the City Council, we have outlined some of the concerns associated with reforestation.
Trees present their share of challenges, particularly when not properly watered and cared for. Those challenges can include invasive and shallow root structures, which can cause damage to sewer and water lines, sprinkler systems, sidewalks, driveways, patios, and other hardscape, and even foundations of homes. Poorly watered and maintained trees can also fall or drop limbs, causing damage to persons and property.
Currently, the City has over 14,000 vacant tree sites. This number represents nearly one-third of all tree sites within the City. This a burden that will result in further deferred costs and visual blight. This practice could result in additional long-term costs, impact quality of life, and compromise the overall aesthetics and characteristics of the community. Staff recommends that the City Council consider whether or not residents can refuse a shared responsibility tree. If residents are allowed to refuse a tree, this will contribute to the already inconsistent plantings caused by the 14,000 removals without replacement.
City staff is presenting the City Council with (3) options or plans for reforestation to restore the 14,000 vacant trees wells throughout the City’s urban forest highlighted under the Financial Impact section of this report.
Grid Pruning
Proper tree maintenance increases the longevity of trees, reduces premature failures, and maximizes the benefits trees provide. While the City currently performs regular tree care and maintenance on over 7,500 trees a year, we believe we can do even better with a more proactive plan set in place for programmed service intervals. A grid pruning schedule, which would be completed by contract crews, ensures that every tree within the City’s urban forest receives inspection at regular, planned intervals providing even more consistent care throughout the City. All trees will be inventoried and tracked through the City’s tree maintenance database.
Education and Enforcement
With the recommended implementation of the UFMP, reforestation efforts, and grid pruning, staff also recommends education and enforcement elements to ensure successful reestablishment of the urban forest. The UFMP will create a community standard for the regular care of City trees and Shared Responsibility Trees. This is especially important with Shared Responsibility Tress growing in parkways (e.g. the area between the curb and the sidewalk). To ensure new plantings are successful, educational elements recommended include informational materials, in-person classes, “Ask an Arborist” newsletter articles, social media posts, and events like Arbor Day, volunteer tree planting events and opportunities, and March Mulch Madness.
The City reserves the right to plant trees in all public spaces and easements as part of the City’s reforestation efforts. These trees will be planted by the City at no cost to the resident. Staff is looking for feedback on whether a resident may not refuse a Shared Responsibility Tree.
COMMISSION AND COMMITTEE ACTION:
The Parks and Recreation Commission received a verbal overview of proposed Urban Forest Management Plan on March 10, 2021, which was received and filed. The draft UFMP with an option for grid pruning was presented at the City Council Study Session on March 24, 2021. City Council recommend proceeding with the implementation of the UFMP with grid pruning. Additionally, City Council requested that this be brought back with a recommendation for baseline pruning and reforestation.
FINANCIAL IMPACT:
The proposed UFMP was completed in partnership with California Urban Forests Council and the Western Chapter International Society of Arboriculture, utilizing funding from Proposition 68, administered through CAL FIRE’s Urban and Community Forestry Grant Program at no cost to the City. The implementation of the UFMP also represents savings to the City by anticipating urban forest needs, cutting down on costs incurred on reactionary basis, helping prevent excessive staff time, and reducing emergency callout situations. Additional costs are our outlined as follows:
Reforestation
To restore the 14,000 vacant trees wells throughout the City’s urban forest, the following options are presented for consideration:
A. 3-Year Replacement Schedule $1,000,000 per year
This aggressive reforestation will quickly and obviously change the look and feel of the City of Corona. This reforestation plan represents nearly 5,000 trees per year refilling vacant tree wells throughout the entire community signifying a deep commitment to Corona’s idealized standards as a Tree City.
B. 5-Year Replacement Schedule $600,000 per year
This reforestation effort will ensure that vacant tree wells are filled in a phased approach with approximately 2,800 trees planted per year. While this is a more modest approach, this manageable pace allows for replanted trees to be better monitored and integrated into the City’s tree inventory database and grid pruning schedule, and gradually returns Corona to its ideal standard.
C. 10-Year Replacement Schedule $300,000 per year
While not as fast as the other options, this approach would allow the City to begin catching up on reforestation with a more modest impact on the City’s budget, however, with a less noticeable impact on the already significant loss of trees. Additionally, estimates are based on industry costs at the time of report. Staff anticipate that over a 10-year period, these costs would significantly inflate.
Grid Pruning
While providing a 5-year grid pruning schedule is budget neutral, there will be catch-up pruning required to achieve a baseline for the next two years to eliminate trees that have not been trimmed in five or more years. This catch-up pruning will result in an additional one-time expenditure totaling $450,000 from the General Fund and LMD’s/CFD’s. Staff has requested $150,000 for FY 21-22 to begin the first year of this 3-year process.
A. 3 Year Grid Pruning $1,000,000 (approx.)
This aggressive model will see that all City trees receive regular pruning every 3-years and every year for palm trees per the highest recommended industry standards. This represents a significant cost to the City and its residents. While this offers the greatest level of efficiency, the costs outweigh the benefits with 5-year pruning being a more manageable operational protocol consistent with other municipalities.
B. 5 Year Grid Pruning Budget Neutral
This option allows the implementation of grid pruning without a significant impact to the budget while providing an optimal level of care for the City’s urban forest. This will benefit the community as a whole. This is highly manageable from a City staffing standpoint, utilizing contracted services, while providing a noticeable increase and consistency of service throughout the community, which will be our Corona standard.
C. No Change in Pruning Schedule Budget Neutral
The City may also choose not to accept a grid pruning schedule. While this does not impact the budget, this continues a more reactive approach to urban forest management. This equates to longer response times and spikes in emergency service requests, resulting in less desirable customer service standards. This model does not offer a consistent and standardized response for the City.
Education and enforcement would be supported through the City’s adopted budget with existing time and resources being allocated toward educational outreach, materials, and events. No additional budget request is required for this element of the UFMP. Should enforcement be required, staff will follow normal cost reimbursement efforts.
As the urban forest matures, the City should expect additional costs for care and maintenance that are unique to the care of an established urban forest. These will be evaluated through routine monitoring and the regular care system now established as the Corona standard. This also ensures the growing replacement value of the urban forest, which aligns with the City’s Strategic Plan. With proper care and maintenance this will be a benefit that provides sense of community that lasts for generations.
ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS:
This action is exempt pursuant to Section 15061(b)(3) of the Guidelines for the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), which states that a project is exempt from CEQA if the activity is covered by the common-sense exemption that CEQA applies only to projects that have the potential for causing a significant effect on the environment. Where it can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that the activity in question may have a significant effect on the environment, the activity is not subject to CEQA. This action is for City Council to approve a tree management plan which includes removal of dead or diseased trees, an activity which is already occurring in the City of Corona, and there is no possibility that approving this plan will have a significant effect on the environment. Therefore, no environmental analysis is required.
PREPARED BY: MOSES CORTEZ, PARK SUPERINTENDENT
PREPARED BY: JASON LASS, RECREATION SERVICES MANAGER
REVIEWED BY: ANNE K. TURER, COMMUNITY SERVICES DIRECTOR
REVIEWED BY: DEAN DERLETH, CITY ATTORNEY
Attachments:
1. Exhibit 1- Ordinance No. 3328 (REDLINE)
2. Exhibit 2 - Ordinance No. 3328 (CLEAN)
3. Exhibit 3 - Urban Forest Management Plan
4. Exhibit 4 - Resolution 2021-029
5. Exhibit 5 - Grid Pruning Presentation - West Coast Arborists